This is another one from the archives, I wrote it five years ago at Wheaton College, after the Class Films…
I’m taking a contextualization class at Wheaton College, in it we learn about other cultures and how to contextualize the gospel. It’s a great class and I’ve really enjoyed what I’ve learned. Basically it’s taught me to look at my culture and say, “how are we not contextualizing the gospel into our culture?” It causes you to look at a lot of things.
Take bridesmaids for example. Did you know that originally the reason for bridesmaids was a pagan belief that they came before the bride to ward off any evil eye that someone might have toward the bride. Weird! But, now it’s a regular part of nearly all Christian marriages. Shall we toss it out as pagan, or is it so a part of our Christian heritage and carries none of the meaning it once did for us? Now take prostitution, is it possible to have a Christian brothel? Obviously not, because it goes against so many basic Christian values. Have we effectively contextualized music? The arts? And so many other things? These are the questions you ask in trying to contextualize. So join me in this case study.
A Christian College host a large event for the students modeled after the Academy awards. Four student films were produced, one for each class, and the event consisted of viewing the films and then giving awards accordingly. The evening started with students arriving quite early at the doors of Edman Chapel. A red carpet was laid out at the central doors, where a limo pulled up and those involved in each film where escorted into the theater. There was much cheering, but the focus was on excitement for friends, rather then the glitz and glamor and focus on who is wearing what that is such the focus of the Academy Awards. The doors opened and students rushed in for seats to view the four films which where all of excellent quality.
After the films a pair of people where introduced to come and announce the winner of best supporting actress. After the introduction three people walked on to the stage. The pair that was introduced stepped up to the microphone and dialogged a bit before announcing the winner. The third person, a female, stood silently in the back holding the Academy Award style trophy. She presented it to the winning actress and then escorted her off the stage. Again, a pair was introduced, three people walked on stage, the pair spoke and the third, a female again, stood silently in the back holding the trophy. She presented it to the winner and escorted him off stage. All evening I watched this happen. Near the end of the ceremonies there where some thank yous and congratulations to those who had helped make the evening come together. Never once did any of the females with the trophies speak, never once were their names mentioned. The only recognition they got was some banter teasingly saying they where stealing a boyfriends attention.
Did our attempt to do a Christian Academy Awards miss something? Is displaying females without a name or a voice, and only recognizing what they look like, Christian? I think we can agree that it is missing something, or it is flawed.
Interesting. I was thinking about something similar while watching Christian artist flash the horns–which means rock on/rock out, Go Texas Longhorns, or the devil depending on your interpretation.
I guess there is the notion of “re-claiming” a word or meaning….or perhaps altering the context in some way.
That an interesting observation. I agree with you that its weird to have these girls be simply eye candy.
Probably the simplest answer is just that they didn’t question assumptions. They were modeling after the regular awards so of course there has to be a pretty girl up on stage to hand out the award.
Nathan,
Not sure how you could ‘re-claim’ the idea of a women being treated as an object. But I hear what your saying in the context of other symbols and sayings.
Jason,
Yeah I think your right they didn’t question it. But that’s what sort of surprises me in this whole thing. This is at Wheaton, a Christian college, lots of critical thinking folks there, and yet it didn’t cross anyone’s mind in the planning that the whole trophy girl thing was a little out of character?
Who knows… I would hope that they just didn’t think of it because if they DID think of it and they decided to go ahead with that sort of objectification, then that is terrible (In my opinion)
The longer I live, the more it seems to me that a lot of people often just don’t question norms and assumptions. They don’t look at situations and ask why are things a certain way. So the norm is to have a pretty girl there, so thats what you have. What do you think?